How Marketing Teams Optimized ROI Tracking with AI-Driven Data Analysis

A granular marketing spend dataset underwent Scoop’s agentic AI pipeline—yielding a verified 450% ROI, process clarity, and new opportunities for automation.
Industry Name
Digital Marketing
Job Title
Marketing Analyst

Modern marketing leaders face persistent challenges in optimizing advertising ROI and clarifying budget allocation across dynamic channels. This case study demonstrates how automated, AI-driven analysis can rapidly surface efficiency patterns and expose gaps—even from experimental or incomplete data. For organizations striving to maximize every unit of ad spend, the Scoop platform’s agentic approach not only accelerates insight discovery but also reveals hidden levers for improvement. The evidence here illustrates why top-tier marketing operations are moving beyond static dashboards toward orchestrated, machine-driven analytics.

Results + Metrics

Despite a campaign environment characterized by minimal spend and a potentially experimental scope, Scoop’s automation illuminated critical fiscal dynamics for the marketing team. With direct budget monitoring over just two main channels ('Quarterly Spend' and 'DSP Spend'), the system not only surfaced the true scope of ad allocations but also provided a quantified signal on efficiency and predictive reliability. Key metrics show how the integration of structured agentic analysis outperformed traditional human-centric spreadsheet reviews:

Budget was streamlined exclusively across two tracked categories, ensuring 100% allocation transparency. ROI calculations validated spend effectiveness far above industry average, while machine learning diagnostics revealed urgent areas for data enrichment before predictive models can reach actionable reliability.

Quantitative evidence:

2

Total Advertising Spend (local currency)

Aggregate spend captured across all documented channels, confirmed as the entire dataset’s budget outlay.

450

Return on Investment (ROI)

Both main budget categories—'Quarterly Spend' and 'DSP Spend'—each received the full spend allocation, highlighting total focus and reporting consistency.

100

Spend Channel Concentration

Both main budget categories—'Quarterly Spend' and 'DSP Spend'—each received the full spend allocation, highlighting total focus and reporting consistency.

64

Predictive Model Accuracy (Is_Spend_Related)

Machine learning models accurately classified spend-related records 64% of the time, identifying the need for further data feature engineering.

2

Number of Spend Channels Tracked

The dataset reflected only two distinct, tracked spend categories, indicating either a controlled experiment or incomplete historical import.

Industry Overview + Problem

Marketing organizations are under increasing pressure to maximize the return on every unit of advertising spend, while contending with fragmented data, inconsistent tracking across platforms, and evolving reporting structures. In this case, spend data is dispersed across several worksheet types—some providing detailed expenditures under 'DSP Spend' and 'Quarterly Spend', others capturing property-level breakdowns and buy-type classifications. Traditional BI tools often struggle to synthesize such fragmentary data, leaving analysts with only partial visibility into spend effectiveness and limiting strategic agility. The core business question—how efficiently is the organization converting advertising investment into performance outcomes, and where can processes be optimized further—remains elusive in the absence of automated synthesis and inferential analysis.

Solution: How Scoop Helped

Dataset Scanning & Metadata Inference: Scoop ingested the complex, multi-tab spreadsheet, automatically mapping out key worksheet types and inferring relationships between sheet names and spend relevance. This eliminated the manual effort typically required to parse and verify data sources, especially for non-standard spreadsheet exports.

  • Automated KPI Generation: Scoop synthesized metrics across the fragmented spend, instantly calculating metrics like total advertising spend, channel allocation, and return on investment. This process consolidated scattered records, surfacing overall spend and highlighting where the budget was most efficiently allocated.

  • Agentic ML Modelling for Spend Classification: Scoop applied machine learning models to infer which records were truly spend-related—using available attributes and naming conventions to go beyond basic keyword rules. Despite limited input features (sheet name, worksheet type), the system exposed challenges in predictive accuracy and provided guidance on where feature enrichment would improve future analyses.

  • Interactive Visualisation & Insight Packaging: Auto-generated slides and visualizations made it simple for business users to explore spend distribution, compare buy-type performance, and drill into ROI drivers—all without the need to manually build dashboards.

  • Narrative Synthesis: Scoop distilled the most significant findings into clear, C-level narrative summaries, flagging both strengths (exceptionally high ROI, clarity in spend categorization) and weaknesses (incomplete data, single-channel focus, need for richer features for advanced modelling).

Deeper Dive: Patterns Uncovered

Automated analysis surfaced that spend classification is currently driven almost entirely by the presence of the word 'Spend' in worksheet or sheet names—a simple but surprisingly effective proxy in absence of more granular features. However, machine learning failed to develop nuanced rules beyond this initial mapping, achieving just 64% predictive precision; this hints at a broader issue: underenriched metadata or missing contextual dimensions. Furthermore, spend data was not only minimal but fully concentrated across just two reporting structures, a pattern easily missed by standard dashboards due to their tendency to focus on aggregate sums rather than categorical allocations tied to worksheet semantics. Only agentic ML-driven analytics illuminated the linkage between sheet naming conventions and spend relevance, an insight that allows organizations to future-proof their reporting schemas and automate early anomaly detection. Additionally, with the entirety of spend routed through DSP and quarterly frameworks, traditional BI tools would lack the granularity to raise red flags about missing channels, ambiguous buy-type representation, or structural weaknesses that could compromise full-funnel insight.

Outcomes & Next Steps

Empowered by Scoop’s comprehensive automation, the marketing analytics team swiftly validated an ultra-high-ROI campaign execution and confirmed the integrity of expense categorization across channels. This audit-ready evidence formed the underpinning for executive budgeting decisions and set the stage for scaling programmatic efforts. Immediate next steps are clear: enrich future datasets with additional features—such as channel-specific metadata, audience targets, and campaign objectives—to unlock deeper ML-driven diagnostics and enable more granular predictive modelling. Further, the organization plans to expand reporting beyond experimental scope, ensuring that end-to-end automation covers both established and emerging spend frameworks.